BARRY ROCHE, Southern CorrespondentA LOCAL councillor in
Cork has called for a review of the way fishing rights are allocated
after a man was jailed for 10 days for refusing to pay a fine for
fishing on a privately-owned fishery on the river Lee.
Cllr Jonathan O’Brien, a Sinn Féin member of Cork City Council,
criticised the system whereby fishing rights to private fisheries on
rivers such as the Lee are leased to angling clubs who then confine
fishing in those stretches to their members.
“It’s ridiculous that an individual landlord can decide who can or
can’t fish the river Lee – fishing on the river should be open to
everyone who buys a fishing licence from the fisheries board.”
Mr O’Brien was speaking following the jailing this week of Donal
Cunningham (44), from St Colmcille Road, Gurranebraher, Cork, after he
refused to pay a fine for unauthorised salmon fishing at a private
fishery at Coolymurraghue on September 29th, 2006.
Mr Cunningham was prosecuted by the Lee Salmon Anglers who have leased
fishing rights downstream of the Anglers’ Rest from Sir Charles
Colthurst of Blarney castle. He was fined €100 at Cork District Court,
and ordered to pay expenses of €274 and costs of €365.
Mr Cunningham appealed the decision to Cork Circuit Court last
December, where Judge Con Murphy affirmed the District Court order.
However Mr Cunningham refused to pay the fine and penalties, and was
arrested on Monday and taken to Cork Prison.
Mr O’Brien said he accepted that due process was followed in the case,
but said it highlighted the need for a review of how fishing rights
were allocated. It seemed bizarre that an angler could pay €137 for a
licence and still not be able to fish a river like the Lee.
Sir Charles Colthurst told The Irish Times he did not wish to comment
on Mr Cunningham’s case. On the issue of fishing rights, he said they
had been allocated by the Land Commission in the 1920s when estates
were broken up.
“Fishing and shooting rights were allocated separately from the land by
the Land Commission – that’s how it happened historically all over the
country, and any review of how they were allocated or seeking any
change would ultimately be a matter for Government.”
Mr Cunningham’s brother, Willie, told The Irish Times his brother was
refusing to pay the fine on principle as he believed that having bought
a salmon licence from the South Western Regional Fisheries Board for
€137, he should be able to fish the river.
“His argument is that the licence says it entitles him to fish for wild
Atlantic salmon and that’s all he was doing – he’s been fishing the
river Lee for the last 30 odd years, and he’s just standing up for his
rights in that regard.”
Lee Salmon Anglers secretary Paul Lawton said the 170-member club had
asked Mr Cunningham for an undertaking not to fish the river on the
beat they lease, and it was only when he refused to give any such
undertaking that they proceeded with a prosecution.
South Western Regional Fisheries Board manager Aidan Barry said anyone
seeking to fish private fisheries needed permission from the owners or
operators of the fishery, in addition to obtaining a salmon fishing
licence from the fishery board.